Wicked Cool Goods

Disclosure: We earn a commission if you buy through links on this site. It does not change the price you pay. We only list products we have reviewed.

iMemories vs Costco Photo Center: Which to Use?

The short version

If you're weighing iMemories vs Costco for digitizing old home movies and photos, the decision mostly comes down to what's in your boxes.

iMemories is a dedicated mail-in digitizing service. You send in film, videotape, and photos. They convert everything to digital files. You pay per item.

Costco is a warehouse retailer first. Its photo center services are generally known to be more limited, and what's offered can vary by warehouse and region. That's general public knowledge, not something from the iMemories offer page — so treat it as a starting point, not a spec sheet.

If you have a large or varied collection — old film reels, obscure tape formats, a mix of everything — a dedicated service like iMemories is likely the more complete option.

What iMemories offers

iMemories professionally converts home movies and photos into digital format. The formats listed on the offer page include:

  • Movie film: 8mm, Super 8, and 16mm
  • Videotapes: Betamax, VHS, VHS-C, 8mm, Hi8, Digital 8, MiniDV, and MicroMini
  • Photographs: prints, slides, and negatives

The process starts with a SafeShip Kit. It includes a crush-proof box, waterproof bags, shock-resistant cushions, and free FedEx shipping. The maker says you don't need to sort or label anything before sending it back — just pack it up and ship it.

There are optional extras. McKenzie AI is an enhancement add-on, and there's an app for streaming your converted memories. Both cost more than the base conversion.

Listed digital conversion pricing:

  • $14.99 per videotape
  • $14.99 per 50 feet of movie film
  • $0.49 per photo

The maker states turnaround is about 2 to 3 weeks once they receive your items.

What Costco is known for (general public knowledge)

To be clear: nothing in this section comes from the iMemories offer page. It's general public knowledge, and it may not match what your local warehouse offers today.

Costco is broadly known as a warehouse retailer. Its photo center has historically focused on prints and, in some cases, photo transfer services. Availability and specific media digitizing services can vary by location and change over time.

The practical takeaway: check your local Costco or its website directly for current photo and digitizing offerings. Don't assume a service exists at your warehouse because it existed somewhere, at some point.

Format coverage

This is where the two options diverge most clearly — at least based on what's documented.

iMemories explicitly covers a wide range of formats:

  • Multiple film gauges, including 8mm, Super 8, and 16mm
  • Many videotape formats, including older ones like Betamax and small-format tapes like MiniDV and MicroMini
  • Prints, slides, and negatives

Costco's format coverage for obscure or older formats — Super 8 film, Betamax, and similar — isn't detailed in the iMemories offer text, and I can't verify it here. You'd need to ask Costco directly.

That last part matters no matter which service you pick. If you have unusual or older formats, confirm the provider can actually handle them before you ship anything. Nobody wants a box of family history sent back with a "we don't do this format" note.

Pricing style

iMemories charges per item: $14.99 per videotape, $14.99 per 50 feet of film, and $0.49 per photo. The offer page shows a 50% off promo at the time of writing.

Costco's pricing for any media services would come from Costco directly. It's not covered in the iMemories offer text, so I won't guess at numbers.

Here's the honest math advice: per-item pricing can add up for large batches. Ten tapes at list price is one thing. Forty tapes plus a stack of film reels plus hundreds of photos is another. Estimate your total for your specific collection, then compare it to whatever Costco quotes you locally. Which one costs less genuinely depends on your collection size, your formats, and what your nearest warehouse offers. There's no universal answer.

One note on buying: purchases made through the offer page go direct from iMemories via a GiddyUp partner offer.

Guarantee and how you receive your files

With iMemories, the maker says you can download your digital masters for free. Those are the converted files — yours to keep and back up however you like.

For ongoing streaming, there's the iMemories Cloud app. It's a paid subscription: $7.99 per month or $49

Check iMemories price